Kirkus Reviews garners a generally positive reputation among its users, with many praising the professional quality of the reviews and the significant marketing advantage that comes with the Kirkus name. Reviewers frequently highlight the insightful and balanced nature of the feedback, which often includes constructive criticism that enhances their work. However, some customers express disappointment regarding the depth of analysis, feeling that the reviews sometimes lack the detailed insights expected given the service's prestige and cost. Communication issues, particularly around timelines, also emerge as a common concern, with some users noting delays that affected their launch plans. Overall, while Kirkus Reviews is recognized for its solid service and industry standing, there are areas for improvement in depth and communication.
A week ago
Decent review service with reliable turnaround. The feedback was helpful though not groundbreaking. Does what it says on the tin, but I've seen more insightful reviews from other services at lower pri... See more
A week ago
Met expectations without exceeding them. The review was competent and fair, giving me good material for marketing. Would use again but might shop around for better value next time.
A week ago
The Kirkus star really makes a difference when pitching to media and bookstores. Professional review that I've been able to use across all my promotional materials.
A week ago
The review quality met expectations and provided useful marketing material. My only complaint is that it took longer than the estimated timeframe, which delayed my launch plans slightly.
Decent review service with reliable turnaround. The feedback was helpful though not groundbreaking. Does what it says on the tin, but I've seen more insightful reviews from other services at lower price points.
Met expectations without exceeding them. The review was competent and fair, giving me good material for marketing. Would use again but might shop around for better value next time.
The Kirkus star really makes a difference when pitching to media and bookstores. Professional review that I've been able to use across all my promotional materials.
The review quality met expectations and provided useful marketing material. My only complaint is that it took longer than the estimated timeframe, which delayed my launch plans slightly.
The review quality is undeniably high and carries real weight in the publishing industry. However, the cost is quite steep for indie authors on a budget. Worth it if you're serious about getting noticed, but definitely an investment.
Generally satisfied with the review quality and the prestige factor. Communication could have been better during the process - felt a bit in the dark about timeline updates. Final product was solid though.
Used Kirkus for my memoir and couldn't be happier. The review was balanced, highlighting both strengths and areas for improvement. Having their name attached definitely helped with credibility when approaching bookstores and libraries.
Kirkus Reviews provided exactly what I needed for my debut novel. Their review was thorough, professional, and gave me valuable insights into how readers might perceive my work. The turnaround time was reasonable and the feedback helped me make important revisions before publication.
Expected more detailed analysis given the reputation and cost. The review felt somewhat surface-level and didn't provide the actionable feedback I was hoping for. Not terrible, but not worth the premium price in my opinion.
The review itself was well-written and fair, but I felt like the reviewer didn't quite grasp the genre conventions I was working within. Still valuable feedback, though I wished for more understanding of my target audience.
Appreciated the honest assessment of my work. The reviewer caught some plot inconsistencies I had missed and provided constructive criticism that improved the final version. Definitely recommend for serious authors.
Outstanding service from start to finish. The review was insightful, professionally written, and really understood what I was trying to achieve with my book. The Kirkus name opens doors that other review services simply can't.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Kirkus Reviews is a book review publication that provides professional critiques and editorial assessments of books across various genres. The service offers reviews for publishers, authors, and readers, helping to evaluate literary works before publication or purchase. Kirkus Reviews has been a recognized name in the publishing industry for providing independent book criticism and recommendations.
This business has claimed their CrowdTrust profile and actively responds to reviews.
We're all about transparency. Companies can't pay to alter or remove reviews from CrowdTrust.
