Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source	Rating	Reviews	Weight	6-mo	Fake risk
Trustpilot Imported Trustpilot reviews	3.6	108	100%	-1.0	● Low

3.6 / 5 overall

108 reviews across 1 scored source

How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Aug 2025.

Last 3 months: 2.7▼ 1.0
12-month avg: 3.6
All-time: 3.6
Category avg: 4.0

Monthly averageCategory average

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Jewelry.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
Company	Overall	Legit	Service	Quality	Value	Trend	Reviews
Effy JewelryThis company	3.6 out of 5 (good)	100 out of 100	3.7 out of 5 (good)	4.0 out of 5 (good)	2.1 out of 5 (poor)	−15%	108
Etsy	1.3 out of 5 (poor)	100 out of 100	1.2 out of 5 (poor)	1.2 out of 5 (poor)	1.1 out of 5 (poor)	—	1,000
Michaels Stores	2.9 out of 5 (fair)	100 out of 100	2.5 out of 5 (poor)	1.9 out of 5 (poor)	1.6 out of 5 (poor)	+4%	1,000
Red Run	4.9 out of 5 (good)	100 out of 100	5.0 out of 5 (good)	4.9 out of 5 (good)	4.9 out of 5 (good)	+2%	397
BARCA Stores	2.6 out of 5 (poor)	100 out of 100	2.2 out of 5 (poor)	3.0 out of 5 (fair)	1.8 out of 5 (poor)	+12%	368

Bottom line: Effy Jewelry is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Red Run scores higher (4.9 vs 2.1).

Reviews

108 reviews of Effy Jewelry. Filter by what matters to you.

3.6ⓘ

Customer reviews (108)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review

N M

1 review

May 3, 2025

I found the ring in the hallway of my…

I found the ring in the hallway of my building in a big box. I thought I had to sign for it, which disappointed me. A 1k ring, I did not sign for, but I have it.

Report

Elva Gill

1 review

Apr 21, 2025

It's a very unique design but thought…

It's a very unique design but thought it was too small for the big price!

Report

Calvin

1 review

Mar 21, 2025

Conquela Dorrell Effy Concierge Department A+++

I can honestly say that I the below is not what I had planned to write. My fiancee and I purchased a wedding ring and band on a cruise ship (no judgement please). Within weeks of her wearing it, diamonds fell out of the ring. After contacting customer support, we were told it was due to having it sized. Effy had us send it in, and they made a new ring sized to fit. Unfortunatly, again, within weeks, diamonds fell out of the ring. At this point, I was done with Effy and wanted a full refund. That's when Conquela stepped in. She understood my frustration and patiently listened to my rants and many texts over a period of a few weeks and gave me gave me numerous options. One of which was to look at the Promise by Effy line of jewelry. After some back and forth, I found a ring, but wanted to know how it would look above and beyond the pictures on the site. Conquela found the ring in house and then sent me pictures and videos of how the ring would look (using her hand as a model). I agreed to stay with Effy and purchased the new ring and band. So far, three weeks into my fiancee wearing the new ring we have lost no diamonds. While I cannot attest to the overall quality of the jewelry (and will fight like hell to get a full refund if this ring loses diamonds), Conquela's patience, responsiveness, and professionalism made all the difference in the world. I am hopeful that the new ring will last a very long time and will bring us no issues.

Report