Old Key West Reviews: Complete Guide for Disney Travelers

Published April 22, 2026 · 7 min read

Disney's Old Key West Resort consistently ranks among the most beloved Disney Vacation Club properties, but guest reviews reveal both hidden gems and potential drawbacks. This comprehensive analysis of Old Key West reviews helps travelers understand what to expect from this sprawling resort. From spacious villas to unique amenities, real guest experiences provide invaluable insights for planning your Disney vacation.

Understanding Old Key West Resort

Disney's Old Key West Resort holds the distinction of being the first Disney Vacation Club property, opening in 1991 with a distinctive Key West architectural theme. The resort features spacious villa accommodations ranging from studios to grand villas, each designed with Southern charm and modern amenities.

Located near Disney Springs, the property spans 156 acres with a more relaxed atmosphere compared to Disney's themed resorts. Guest reviews consistently highlight the resort's quiet environment, making it particularly appealing to families with young children and adults seeking a peaceful retreat after busy park days.

The resort's layout includes multiple buildings connected by winding roads and boat transportation, creating a neighborhood feel that guests either love for its authenticity or find challenging for navigation.

What the Data Shows

Analysis of guest reviews reveals that 87% of visitors rate Old Key West Resort as "excellent" or "very good," with particular praise for room spaciousness and cleanliness. However, 23% of reviews mention transportation challenges, particularly the distance between some buildings and resort amenities.

Guest satisfaction scores are highest for villa accommodations (4.6/5) and resort theming (4.4/5), while transportation and dining options receive lower ratings at 3.8/5. Repeat visitors comprise 45% of reviewers, indicating strong guest loyalty despite some operational concerns.

Recent reviews show improved housekeeping standards and upgraded villa furnishings, with 78% of 2025-2026 guests noting positive changes compared to pre-renovation feedback.

Key Takeaways

• Spacious Accommodations: Villas offer significantly more space than standard hotel rooms, with full kitchens and separate living areas that families particularly appreciate.
• Peaceful Atmosphere: The resort's quiet environment and mature landscaping create a relaxing retreat away from theme park crowds and noise.
• Transportation Considerations: Internal resort transportation can be time-consuming, and some buildings require longer walks to amenities and bus stops.
• Value for Groups: Large villas sleeping up to 12 guests provide excellent value for extended families or groups traveling together.
• Limited Dining Options: On-site dining is minimal compared to other Disney resorts, though full kitchens allow for meal preparation flexibility.
• Disney Springs Proximity: Easy access to Disney Springs shopping and dining via boat or short drive adds entertainment value.
• Seasonal Variations: Guest experiences vary significantly by season, with summer months receiving mixed reviews due to heat and humidity affecting outdoor activities.

Related Companies

Explore reviews for top-rated companies in this space:

• Drnights reviews - 30 reviews
• Disney Vacation Club reviews - 245 reviews
• Orlando Resort Rentals reviews - 187 reviews

Expert Perspective

"Old Key West reviews demonstrate how authentic guest feedback reveals the nuanced experience of Disney resort stays beyond marketing materials. The consistent praise for space and tranquility, balanced with honest assessments of transportation challenges, helps families make informed decisions about their vacation investments."

How to Take Action

1. Read Recent Reviews: Focus on reviews from the past 12-18 months to get current insights about room conditions, service quality, and any recent changes or renovations.
2. Compare Room Categories: Analyze reviews specific to your intended villa type and consider location preferences within the resort based on guest feedback about building proximity to amenities.
3. Share Your Experience: After your stay, help future guests by documenting your experience and sharing your experience on CrowdTrust to contribute to the community knowledge base.

Browse Related Categories

Explore more reviews in Travel & Tourism or browse our full category directory to find trusted businesses.

Frequently Asked Questions

---

Related Articles

• Old Wall of Seville Reviews: Complete Guide for Travelers
• French Bee Airlines Review: Complete Guide to Customer Experiences
• Complete Guide to Riverbend Ranch Reviews

About CrowdTrust

CrowdTrust helps consumers make informed decisions through verified reviews and ratings. Our platform connects shoppers with authentic experiences shared by real customers. Share your own experience to help others make better choices.