I toured a home and applied during the middle of the week, the day a property hit the websites. Afterward, I didn't hear back from them until the following Monday, and it was a follow up to the tour, during which I informed them that I already had an application several days old. Their background check, which I apparently perused before they did, showed no negative rental history and excellent credit. They said they would look into it and let me know regarding their decision. I attempted to contact them the following day with no answers to phone, text, or e-mail, and the day after that required a call to their national office after attempting the aforementioned in order to get a notification that the home had already been rented out.
The other homes in the area that my application fee made me eligible for were either too expensive or didn't take dogs, so I am essentially out that money. However, what is most irritating was the lack of timeliness and the lack of communication, as well as the lack of availability. I was in the area following a change of station for the Army, and due to the complexities of Covid on the Army, I wasn't able to start house hunting until I got out here. I would have gone with another company and moved on to other properties if a decision had been made in a reasonable time. In my past, the longest I went between an application and getting a decision was four days. Taking a week to tell a person that you already rented out your property to someone else is asinine.
To rub salt on the wound, the aforementioned property, at the time of this writing, was still showing as available on their main website, as well as various rental websites.
Clearly someone is having success renting from these guys, or they wouldn't be in business. But based on my experiences and other reviews that I have seen, you're gambling with your money. I question how many other people are in the same exact situation I am after applying. I'm willing to bet it's more than a few.